Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Elliot Jager's avatar

This one arrived via email:

I have been reading your posts on the current situation. I'm puzzled.

We sort of know that the public, including media pundits, have been (and continue to be)) played. Not everything we hear or see is apparently obviously comprehensible. So my question is how can you be so confident that your take is in the right direction.

I am not quibbling about epistemology. I just wonder if you are taking your opinions/speculations far too seriously. Like so many people, especially pundits, you seem to be letting wishful thinking affect your analysis.

So I humbly suggest that you sprinkle a bunch of IMHOs among your speculations, both for the sake of your readers and as your own reminders.

Let's hope to hear good news.

Reuben F

Expand full comment
Elliot Jager's avatar

Thanks for these messages via WhatsApp

"Great perceptive article , Elliot 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽" (Jeff G)

"Unfortunately, Israel is too dependent on military aid and sales from the U.S. Israel is now at the mercy of Donald Trump and every President who comes after him. Trump has only been in office for 6 months, and every day there is something new. Our future in the Middle East is like a rollercoaster ride. How will we ever feel secure again? Yesterday morning, we were lavishing praise on the US attack, until later that evening, we realised that the Iranian attack on the US base in Qatar was staged to let Iran save face.  What a joke!" (Marlene H)

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts